The Hobbit

Reader’s Review

This classic has been loved by many for generations, and continues to fascinate children and adults. It is an easier read than the Lord of the Rings Trilogy, but the language may be complicated for younger children. In addition there is a fair amount of violence (though not gory) that may disturb younger children. There are some good themes including loyalty, friendship and bravery. Those who enjoy fantasy and magical creatures such as elves and goblins will certainly enjoy the many adventures of Bilbo the hobbit. Those who prefer realistic fiction may find it a challenging read.

To look out for

• Islamic Values: The book is based on mythical creatures such as wizards, elves, goblins, trolls and of course a dragon. Magic is very much a part of their life, and little in the book is true of real life. The love of wealth is emphasized greatly, and the treasures of the dragon are described extensively. However the main character is not as enchanted by material wealth as some of the other characters. In addition there are numerous descriptions of smoking tobacco in a pipe, and many of the characters love to drink alcohol and get drunk many times.
• Violence: Bilbo and his companions are captured on a number of occasions, and their lives are often in danger. In one occasion they are caught, tied and almost cooked over a fire. In another Bilbo is lost in a dark cave with creature that continually talks about eating him. There are numerous battles and fights with other creatures and armies, plenty of sword fighting, and some deaths, including important characters. A goblin head is described as being atop a gate.